The role of feedback and guidance as intervention methods to foster computational thinking in educational robotics learning activities for primary school

Morgane Chevalier, Christian Giang, Laila El-Hamamsy, Evgeniia Bonnet, Vaios Papaspyros, Jean-Philippe Pellet, Catherine Audrin, Margarida Romero, Bernard Baumberger, Francesco Mondada

January 2022 - Computers & Education

Abstract

Computational thinking (CT) is considered an emerging competence domain linked to 21st-century competences, and educational robotics (ER) is increasingly recognised as a tool to develop CT competences. This is why researchers recommend developing intervention methods adapted to classroom practice and providing explicit guidelines to teachers on integrating ER activities.

The present study thus addresses this challenge. Guidance and feedback were considered as critical intervention methods to foster CT competences in ER settings. A between-subjects experiment was conducted with 66 students aged 8 to 9 in the context of a remote collaborative robot programming mission, with four experimental conditions. A two-step strategy was employed to report students' CT competence (their performance and learning process). Firstly, the students' CT learning gains were measured through a pre-post-test design. Secondly, video analysis was used to identify the creative computational problem-solving patterns involved in the experimental condition that had the most favourable impact on the students’ CT scores.

Results show that delayed feedback is an effective intervention method for CT development in ER activities. Subject to delayed feedback, students are better at formulating the robot behaviour to be programmed, and, thus, such a strategy reinforces the anticipation process underlying the CT.

---

Reference:

@article{chevalier2022role,
  title={The role of feedback and guidance as intervention methods to foster computational thinking in educational robotics learning activities for primary school},
  author={Chevalier, Morgane and Giang, Christian and El-Hamamsy, Laila and Bonnet, Evgeniia and Papaspyros, Vaios and Pellet, Jean-Philippe and Audrin, Catherine and Romero, Margarida and Baumberger, Bernard and Mondada, Francesco},
  journal={Computers \& Education},
  pages={104431},
  year={2022},
  publisher={Elsevier}
}